Upload a Photo Upload a Video Add a News article Write a Blog Add a Comment
Blog Feed News Feed Video Feed All Feeds

Folders

All 1183
 

 

Essay - Missing the NYRR New York Mini 10-K - RRW

Published by
RunnerSpace.com   Jun 12th 2020, 12:30pm
Comments

ESSAY - MISSING THE MINI
By David Monti, @d9monti
(c) 2020 Race Results Weekly, all rights reserved - Used with permission.

(12-Jun) -- It's ironic that out of the thousands of road races which have been cancelled in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the one that I will miss the most is one that I have never run --nor could ever run-- the NYRR New York Mini 10-K which would have been held for the 49th time tomorrow.  Famously, "the Mini" was the first-ever road race in the world for women, founded in 1972 as the Crazylegs Mini Marathon by New York Road Runners, which opened the door for gender equality in distance running, a sport which had been a male bastion for decades.  Exactly 216,988 women have finished the race, and the Mini helped create momentum for the women's marathon to be included in the Olympic Games for the first time in 1984.

It's noteworthy that the Mini had never before been cancelled. The event had survived all the ups and downs of New York City since 72 intrepid women finished the first edition of the race led by a California teenager named Jacki Dixon: the building, destruction, and rebuilding of the World Trade Center; the reign of terror of "Son of Sam" killer David Berkowitz; the financial crises of the 1970's and 2000's; the blackout of 1977; seven different mayors; seven New York Yankees World Series titles; and even the murder of John Lennon.  The Mini endured.

In a speech commemorating the 50-year anniversary of New York Road Runners in 2008, then president and CEO Mary Wittenberg remarked: "Fifty years ago when New York Road Runners began on June 4th (1958)... women were nowhere in sight in the sport of distance running.  It was considered heresy that women would go out and run hard, and run long."

But the Mini changed all of that.  The race provided a grand platform for some of the greatest runners in history to compete against each other while being followed by thousands of ordinary women behind them who celebrated their personal running accomplishments.  International winners included many of the sport's legendary athletes: Grete Waitz of Norway (five wins from 1979 to 1984), Tegla Loroupe of Kenya (five wins from 1993 to 2000), Lornah Kiplagat of Kenya and the Netherlands (four wins from 2003 through 2007), Mary Keitany of Kenya (three wins from 2015 through 2018), Ingrid Kristiansen (two wins in 1986 and 1988), Linet Masai of Kenya (two wins in 2010 and 2011), and Paula Radcliffe of Great Britain (2001).  American winners included Francie Larrieu-Smith (1985), Judi St. Hilaire (1990), Anne Marie Letko (1994), Deena Kastor (2004), Molly Huddle (2014) and Sara Hall (2019).  Hall was the first Mini winner to also be crowned national champion when the race hosted the USATF 10-K Championships for Women last year for the first time.

The Mini will always be close to my heart because it was the first race for which I worked as an elite athlete coordinator, a role I played on a consulting basis for NYRR for 19 years from April, 2001, to March, 2020.  I was first hired to recruit and manage the elite field for the 2001 race (the 30th edition) by late race director Allan Steinfeld.  In mid-April, he handed me a thin, manila folder which had the recruiting documents for the previous year's race, and told me to get to work.  Honestly, I had no idea what I was doing.

But luck was on my side.  I managed first to recruit the 1996 Olympic 10,000m champion, Fernanda Ribeiro of Portugal, then wrangled a good supporting cast of international women: Restituta Joseph of Tanzania, Florence Barsosio of Kenya, Ludmila Petrova of Russia, Masako Chiba of Japan, Silvia Sommaggio of Italy, and Carol Montgomery of Canada among others.  Not bad.

But several weeks later, Paula Radcliffe's husband and manager, Gary Lough, contacted NYRR and she was looking to run the race. After some back and forth (by fax!) she agreed to come.  I looked forward to a great battle between Ribeiro and Radcliffe.

But that's not what happened.  Radcliffe stormed away from the field at the gun, and crushed the hilly one-loop course in 30:47, the second-fastest 10-K ever by a woman at the time.  Ribeiro literally limped to the finish in seventh place after injuring her ankle (I had to scoop her up in my arms and carry her to the medical tent for treatment).  After the race, we all went to the now-defunct Josie's restaurant on the Upper West Side for lunch. As Paula ate her salmon burger, I realized that I was now part of something truly special.  The Mini wasn't just a race, but rather a turning point in sports history.

For the next 18 years I always gave the Mini by absolute best effort.  NYRR saw the Mini as an integral part of its heritage, so through multiple title sponsors --and even no sponsor-- they invested in the race year after year, keeping it at a high level. Women loved to run the event (when I was recruiting athletes I would tell them it was the gift they should give to themselves). The NYRR staff always gave the athletes top treatment, and my wife, Jane, helped coordinate athlete hospitality.  My chest would swell as I sat on the lead vehicle the second Saturday in June to watch the magnificent field of women getting ready to start on Central Park West at Columbus Circle.  I don't think there is a more majestic start in road racing.

Although I can't run any more due to a pesky knee injury, I'll be walking 10-K on my own on Saturday to honor the more than a quarter million women who have entered the race, and the hundreds of thousands more who will run it in the years ahead after it returns.  When the race comes back, I will be there to continue to tell the story of how one event changed everything for women who had but a simple request: let me run.


PHOTO: The start of the 2019 NYRR New York Mini 10-K (photo by David Monti for Race Results Weekly)

PHOTO: Paula Radcliffe on her way to winning the 2001 NYRR New York Mini 10-K (historic photo; photographer unknown)

PHOTO: (left to right) Gary Lough, Jane Monti, Paula Radcliffe and David Monti after the 2001 NYRR New York Mini 10-K (photo by Mary Wittenberg)



More news

3 comment(s)
darn
I was there as a spectator. It was exciting as always but also sad.

There were hardly any people watching the race other than the people who work for the NYRR.org.

Of course this was intentional. Apparently.

The race was held an hour earlier than usual, at 7 AM instead of 8 AM and the location of the start line and finish line had been changed. The route was still one circle around Central Park but it was a counter-clock wise loop.
Since there were certain health-code guidelines to prevent large crowd gatherings the traditional start at Columbus Circle could not be carried out. Also reportedly there were only some 3 thousand runners participating. The Women's MIni Marathon has had more participants than that except maybe when it was first instigated back in the early 1970s. Also there were a few more "waves" this year. Basically there are two different race-start times, the one for the wheelchair racers and the one for all runners both elites and regular runners. The elites will go many paces faster than the weekend athletes or semi-elite runners.
This year some 15 minutes after the women's wheelchair race got underway the elite females were set off on the course afterward without any other runners to start the run along with them, and then to my best understanding there would be about another two or three, maybe four waves so that there aren't a lot of runners at once on the course. So it seemed.
Also there weren't anywhere near as many barricades or race marshalls or closed-off areas as in previous years. I found I was very easily able to make my way from the start line area to the finish line area by going straight through the transverse, from its east side to its west side.
In the past the finish line area was so guarded and specially set-up that a person had to make his or her way completely around it and go through certain side walkways to eventually get there..

Regarding the regular participants, it was odd seeing runners or small groups of runners spaced very far apart from other runners along the route when normally there are throngs of runners along the route shoulder to shoulder different ones a few paces behind others especially during the first two or so hours of the entire race. Actually, races with not so many participants are overall better I would say, but it was as if this event was really watered down and at least in a major way, it was. .

The NY Women's Mini is one of the more high-profile races even though it is a short course compared to a complete marathon. Also the top competetors take part in it, but this year the prize money for the first place finisher was under $8000 whereas in the past the prize money was $25,000 and perhaps more.
I am not sure if the lower prize money was to prevent "too many" elite runners from trying to take part. Maybe.
Perhaps there was less prize money to dole out.

I heard that the NYRR.org donated money and equipment and supplies to first responders and medical workers during the earlier stages of the Covid epidemic in 2020. Nice.
Yet according to some unspecified information on the internet which mostly was from the NYRR.org website itself, the NYRR.org is of "non profit" status and also solicits and accepts donations. (I sometimes get letters from them asking me to donate).
But I wonder.
It seems that the NYRR.org had probably not made much money when all races were cancelled for at least a year. It seems that the organization could not have made money from race-entry fees.

Perhaps prize money to elite winners had to be drastically reduced. Of course I should emphasize I do not entirely know about the system regarding who decides and pays out the prize money to winning athletes.

As far as the elite field , in a way it was hard to know who would win this race, and in a way it was quite predictabe who would not come in among the first three finishers.

It did seem that Sarah Hall might be the top American female. She had done excellently in some recent races. But after such intense performances, could she pull it off again? Did she have to "rest" her pace and rest her winning streak for other upcoming races?

There were some other top females too, especially the African runners.
Edna Kipligat was participating. She had reportedly become a citizen of the US recently and though she was still a tough competitior, she was now in her early 40s.
Molly Sidel seemed to be one of the tougher American runners and she is younger than Sarah Hall but could she defeat the dominant Hall? There was also Emma Bates, Laura Thweatt, and Molly Huddle who really seemed to be a crowd favorite.

Sarah Hall of course went on to defend her title spectacularly.
Some of the other top runners such as Molly Huddle, and Allie Kieffer sadly fell way back and did not get to be among the top 10.

To this one obscure observer at the finish line area, it was apparent that Huddle was disappointed. But of course so were several other elite runners.
Huddle had won the NYC Half Marathon, the NY Women's Mini Marathon, and had several other outstanding wins in her career. Was it all slowly fading?
(As of this writing, the big news in the running world is that Huddle has dropped out of the Olympic trials altogether due to some persistant injuries. Very heartbreaking indeed).

These competitive races are so thrilling except to people who don't care at all for the sport of running, but there are sad moments in which athletes who have accomplished so much may just find that their bodies start to betray them, and/or all else just does not fall into place and even though there is still a lot of potential, the great wins are mainly in the past.

In the wheelchair division Susannah Scaroni went on to defeat the great Tatyana McFadden by a wide margin. The thrid place wheelchair finisher was well behind McFadden.

Maybe next year the NYC Women's Mini Marathon will resume with much more participants, more spectators, more of the atmosphere of a sport event, and of course, maybe a greater amount of prize money for the winners.
But after essentially an entire year in which the NYRR.org was on haitus from running events except perhaps for "virtual" ones, maybe it may never be the same.
The Covid epidemic did seem to rush a certain deterioration point that would have been reached anyway, or maybe had already been reached.

Actually the very high-profile running events such as the marathon have become too much of a spectacle in which there are just excessive throngs of people jogging or walking through the race course at least regarding the running events in NYC, but I would say it is probably the same most everywhere else since most other running events all over the world seem to have been fashioned like those in NYC.
No matter how it is marketed, the races are not better because they are "bigger," meaning mearely more crowded.

The NYRR.org has always been significantly different from the original New York Road Runner's Club. Those who were members of the original NYCRRC and who can remember the older days of that club were not too keen about the transition from club to "organization" not that the original club was so perfect itself, IMO.

But in retrospect this year's Women's Mini Marathon was more bitter than sweet.
darn
Approximately a month back (at least), news on the NY Road Runner's website was that the NY Women's Mini Marathon was cancelled. I actually could not find much to read about it. It seemed that it was mainly thought of as insignificant. A lot of other races got cancelled nationwide, world wide. But a few days before the Mini was to take place I found this essay on this site. It says much of what I have been thinking. It is a matter of opinion but The NY Women's Mini Marathon is special. A lot of other running events got canceled for the first time in their history (the NYC Half Marathon, The Boston Marathon etc), and yet if you think about it, the Women's Mini Marathon began humbly and yet with much political fanfare that had to do with the Women's rights movement. Reportedly, there were only some 78 women who were interested enough in trying it when the event first took place in the early or mid 1970's. It is interesting to think what drove those women when apparently most women were not interested in running a 6-mile race or maybe they just had no idea of it. The Mini Marathon grew to become a very popular all-women's run and the world's best female runners have competed in it.

After hearing about this year's numerous race cancellations, I wondered if the MIni Marathon would take place like the Tokyo Marathon (2020) did, that is , only elite runners would participate. Then, it could have meant that there would only be some 78 or fewer competitors including wheelchair racers and it would have meant that the number of participants was particularly low since the race first took place decades ago. That would have been an ironic and interesting outcome, but the Mini was completely cancelled.

Today (June 13 2020) I went out to Central Park, which I live only a few blocks away from, just to be at the area where the race would have taken place. There were police barricades around the Columbus Circle area where the starting line of the run has almost always been ( From my best recollection, there was one time approximately in the early 1990's in which Central Park West from 59th street to 90th street was not closed off, and the race took place completely within the park), but today the barricades were to close off Trump Tower and the surrounding area from protesters and/or to prevent large public gatherings. Otherwise, those barricades would have been to section off the starting line area so that the race can get underway. I wondered if I would see a small group of women, dedicated runners, just gathering, 6-feet apart in the area to run through the race course, just for the spirit of an event that, yes , has never been cancelled through stock-market crashes, social changes, different presidents, mayors and administrations, 9/11, and everything else New York City and the nation has been through. The area was busy with some traffic, bikers and regular joggers and people trying to enjoy the outdoors, but it was still solitary and deserted. In fact, it was a bit chilly in the early morning and it seems that it would have been good weather for a 10-K run.
I wondered which world-class female runners would have participated, who would have won.
I actually liked the strong competition of the event, the sport, the adrenaline. I never agreed much with how the race was presented by the Road Runner's, as "women's solidarity." I thought it was superficial politics. Yet,the Saturday in June when the Women's Mini Marathon took place was always special even though the Mini is a run that takes not much more than half an hour for the elite runners to complete, and it is over as soon as it begins.
I always felt wistful when it was all over and I would have to wait another year to watch it again.

I had only run in the Mini a few times in the early 1990s. Unfortunately I physically became unable to tolerate as much running as I used to do when younger. I had to become a complete spectator. I had seen falls, heat-exhaustion and people helping others cross the finish line.

There had been different "main sponsors" of the race throughout its history. Back in the late 90's only local elite runners participated (no world-class runners) when "Leggs" stopped sponsoring the race. Later on an "Anti -Smoking" organization once sponsored the race and it seemed more like a political march against the Tobacco companies as far as a lot of the walkers taking part.
I think that the event is better without that kind of atmosphere.

I actually think that some really big races, with thousands of runners should be smaller rather than be a parade of walkers, but It seems that running events may not get back to what they used to be, ever.

The New York Women's Mini Marathon may not take place next year either.
darn
Approximately a month back (at least), news on the NY Road Runner's website was that the NY Women's Mini Marathon was cancelled. I actually could not find much to read about it. It seemed that it was mainly thought of as insignificant. A lot of other races got cancelled nationwide, world wide. But a few days before the Mini was to take place I found this essay on this site. It says much of what I have been thinking. It is a matter of opinion but The NY Women's Mini Marathon is special. A lot of other running events got canceled for the first time in their history (the NYC Half Marathon, The Boston Marathon etc), and yet if you think about it, the Women's Mini Marathon began humbly and yet with much political fanfare that had to do with the Women's rights movement. Reportedly, there were only some 78 women who were interested enough in trying it when the event first took place in the early or mid 1970's. It is interesting to think what drove those women when apparently most women were not interested in running a 6-mile race or maybe they just had no idea of it. The Mini Marathon grew to become a very popular all-women's run and the world's best female runners have competed in it.

After hearing about this year's numerous race cancellations, I wondered if the MIni Marathon would take place like the Tokyo Marathon (2020) did, that is , only elite runners would participate. Then, it could have meant that there would only be some 78 or fewer competitors including wheelchair racers and it would have meant that the number of participants was particularly low since the race first took place decades ago. That would have been an ironic and interesting outcome, but the Mini was completely cancelled.

Today (June 13 2020) I went out to Central Park, which I live only a few blocks away from, just to be at the area where the race would have taken place. There were police barricades around the Columbus Circle area where the starting line of the run has almost always been ( From my best recollection, there was one time approximately in the early 1990's in which Central Park West from 59th street to 90th street was not closed off, and the race took place completely within the park), but today the barricades were to close off Trump Tower and the surrounding area from protesters and/or to prevent large public gatherings. Otherwise, those barricades would have been to section off the starting line area so that the race can get underway. I wondered if I would see a small group of women, dedicated runners, just gathering, 6-feet apart in the area to run through the race course, just for the spirit of an event that, yes , has never been cancelled through stock-market crashes, social changes, different presidents, mayors and administrations, 9/11, and everything else New York City and the nation has been through. The area was busy with some traffic, bikers and regular joggers and people trying to enjoy the outdoors, but it was still solitary and deserted. In fact, it was a bit chilly in the early morning and it seems that it would have been good weather for a 10-K run.
I wondered which world-class female runners would have participated, who would have won.
I actually liked the strong competition of the event, the sport, the adrenaline. I never agreed much with how the race was presented by the Road Runner's, as "women's solidarity." I thought it was superficial politics. Yet,the Saturday in June when the Women's Mini Marathon took place was always special even though the Mini is a run that takes not much more than half an hour for the elite runners to complete, and it is over as soon as it begins.
I always felt wistful when it was all over and I would have to wait another year to watch it again.

I had only run in the Mini a few times in the early 1990s. Unfortunately I physically became unable to tolerate as much running as I used to do when younger. I had to become a complete spectator. I had seen falls, heat-exhaustion and people helping others cross the finish line.

There had been different "main sponsors" of the race throughout its history. Back in the late 90's only local elite runners participated (no world-class runners) when "Leggs" stopped sponsoring the race. Later on an "Anti -Smoking" organization once sponsored the race and it seemed more like a political march against the Tobacco companies as far as a lot of the walkers taking part.
I think that the event is better without that kind of atmosphere.

I actually think that some really big races, with thousands of runners should be smaller rather than be a parade of walkers, but It seems that running events may not get back to what they used to be, ever.

The New York Women's Mini Marathon may not take place next year either.
History for DyeStat.com
YearVideosNewsPhotosBlogs
2024 1980 522 22517  
2023 5382 1361 77508  
2022 4892 1212 58684  
Show 25 more
 
+PLUS highlights
+PLUS coverage
Live Events
Get +PLUS!